Hotels on Fire Island

A list of places to stay on Fire Island. Most of these places are for week-long or weekend stays but may accommodate a one-night stay.

Ocean Beach

Clegg's Hotel
478 Bayberry Lane
631-583-5399
Features: Resort hotel open May-September. Five-minute walk to beach, apartments with bay view, guest room with garden view, bicycles, air conditioning.
Rooms: 20
cleggshotel.com

Palms Hotel
168 Cottage Walk
631-583-8870
Features: Resort hotel open year-round. Walk to beach, kitchenettes, barbecue area, pets OK, children free.
Rooms: 19
thepalmsatoceanbeach.com

Seasons Bed & Breakfast Bay House
468 Denhoff Walk
631-583-8295
Features: Bed and breakfast open year-round. Rustic beach house, short walk to beach, bicycles, air conditioning, color TV, afternoon tea.
Number of room: 11

Houser's Hotel on the Bay
781-85 Evergreen Walk
631-583-8900
Features:
housersbar.com/hotel.html

Place in the Sun
987 Surfview Walk
631-583-5716
Features: Guest house open May 15-Sept. 15. All non-smoking rooms, sauna, satellite TV, near beach, refrigerator available.
Rooms: 3

Seashore Condo Motel
78 E. Bayview Walk
631-583-5860
Features: Resort motel open May-October. Color satellite TV, air conditioning, microwave, barbecue, waterview.
Rooms: 24

Ocean Bay Park

Fire Island Hotel & Resort
631-583-8000
Features: Full-service hotel open May 15-Oct. 1. Full-service resort, heated pool, restaurant, waterview, walk to beach.
Rooms: 43

Cherry Grove

ANIMA Retreat-at-the-Beach
185 Holly Walk
631-597-3080
Features: Retreat house open May-October. Near Sunken Forest, walk to beach, decks and gardens, available for day retreats.
Rooms: 1 house with double bedrooms

Belvedere Guest House
36 Bayview Walk
631-597-6448
Features: Resort hotel open May-October. Frequented by men only, pool, health club, walk to beach, whirlpool, sundeck.
Rooms: 20
belvederefireisland.com

Dune Point Fire Island Rentals
Lewis Walk
631-597-6261
Features: Studios and apartments open year-round. All rooms with kitchenettes, waterfront with beach, private terraces, picnic/barbecue area, pets OK, maid service.
Rooms: 27

Fire Island Pines

Hotel Ciel
Harbor Walk
631-597-6500 ext. 26
Features: Great views of the water, Blue Whale restaurant and bar, gym
thepinesfireisland.com

Madison Fire Island Pines
631-597-6061
Features: Open Memorial Day through Labor Day. Brand new, it's a minute from the ferry, a minute from the beach. Pool, rooftop views, hot tubs, high-speed Internet, flat-screen satellite TVs, trainers and masseuses by appointment, iPod docks. Will book your travel, too.
madisonfi.com

Pines Bluff Overlook
362 Ocean Walk
631-597-3064
Features: Hotel open May 1-Oct. 31. Short-term shares available. Apartment and hotel-style rooms. All rooms are recently renovated, have private baths, air conditioning, bar, refrigerators, WiFi, private access to the outside deck, Rooftop Jacuzzi.
pinesbluffoverlook.com

Pines Paradise Bed & Breakfast
631-597-4130 or 212-368-7058
Features: A private compound rentable by room or in its entirety. Ten feet from the bay, five minutes from ocean, 10 minutes from ferry. Choose from master bedroom with Jacuzzi, king-sized bed and private deck; Waterview bedroom with adjacent bath and bay views; Smaller two twin-bed pool room, which shares a bath with the main house.
Rooms: 3
pinesparadise.com

Pines Place
Ocean Walk
631-597-6162
Features: Seven walks from the harbor Rooms vary between shared baths, private baths and deluxe rooms with ocean views.
Common living area, kitchen, pool, evening cocktail hour.
Phone: 631-597-6162

Robins Rest

The Ocean View
631-583-0375
Features: Hotel open Memorial Day to Labor Day. A 10-minute walk from Ocean Beach, this hotel is upstairs from Tequila Jack's restaurant.
Rooms: 10

Hotels on Fire Island

Weekend Getaways

New York Real Estate

Popular stories

Recent Multimedia