Ask an Expert: Is it okay to smoke e-cigarettes in the lobby?
Since it isn't illegal (yet) to 'smoke' electronic cigarettes in New York City restaurants, bars or parks, is it okay to do it in the public spaces of an apartment building? What if the entire building is non-smoking - can you smoke one inside your apartment?
Unless your building has a rule forbidding the use of e-cigarettes in common spaces, it's probably okay for now, say our experts.
"Given the complete lack of any type of governmental regulation the likely answer is that e-cigarette would be allowed in the public areas of a residential building," says co-op and condo attorney Dean Roberts of Norris McLaughlin & Marcus.
In the absence of a law or regulation prohibiting "vaping" (as the use of e-cigarettes is colloquially referred to), the activity would have to constitute a nuisance - either as defined in a lease or by law, says Roberts.
"To be a legal nuisance, an activity has to be extremely disruptive or seriously affect the health and safety of residents. E-cigarettes," which use nicotine instead of tobacco and emit water vapor, not smoke, "would not seem to meet that standard as they are fairly innocuous," says Roberts.
Furthermore, while a building could pass a rule "forbidding this activity in common areas, I do not believe it could ban the activity in individual apartments," says Roberts.
Property manager Thomas Usztoke of Douglas Elliman Property Management says his company hasn't heard any complaints yet, but "we’re aware of actions elsewhere [outside the apartment-building context] which have resulted in e-cigarette bans in public spaces, indoors and out, and expect NYC government will react in kind fairly quickly."
As to whether e-cigarettes can impair indoor air quality, "Unfortunately, there isn’t yet much research available about the possible impact of these products and indoor air quality," says air quality specialist Maria Vizzi of Indoor Environmental Solutions.
Teri Karush Rogers is the founder and editor of BrickUnderground.com, the online survival guide to finding a NYC apartment and living through the aftermath. To see more expert answers or to ask a real estate question, click here.