EARLY VOTING STARTS: Massive turnout across the city as New Yorkers cast ballots in 2025 NYC Mayor’s Race

New Yorkers flooded the polls on Saturday, turning out in record numbers for the first day of early voting.

According to figures from the city’s Board of Elections, participation citywide more than quadrupled compared with 2021, and more than doubled the turnout on the first day of the June primaries.

Manhattan led the surge with 24,046 voters casting ballots on Oct. 25, up from 4,563 on the first day of early voting in 2021 and more than double the 10,003 recorded during the primary.

Brooklyn followed with 22,105 check-ins, up from 3,751 in 2021 and 10,244 in the primary. Queens had 19,045 voters, the Bronx 7,793, and Staten Island 6,420, all significantly higher than both prior elections.

Overall, 79,409 voters were checked in citywide, compared with 15,418 on the first day of early voting in the 2021 general election and 30,553 during the first day of the June primary.

Manhattan early voters speak out

During Zohran Mamdani and Andrew Cuomo’s last showdown at the polls during June’s Democratic primary, the Queens Assembly Member notched a significant edge over the former Governor — 44% to 36%. By borough, Mamdani won a majority in Manhattan, Brooklyn, and Queens, while Cuomo came out on top in the Bronx and Staten Island.

In Manhattan, Mamdani had a six-point lead over Cuomo, but the former governor managed to hold on to pockets of support, such as in areas of the Lower East Side.

As voters went to the polls there on the first day of early voting, those who spoke to amNewYork Saturday voiced a wide range of opinions — from frustration with both major parties to enthusiasm for front-runner and Democratic Socialist Zohran Mamdani’s campaign. According to most opinion polls, Mamdani’s campaign is ahead by double-digit margins coming into the general election.

Nilka, a lifelong Democrat who recently left the party, cast her ballot for Republican Curtis Sliwa.

“I was a diehard Democrat. But after COVID, I changed to no party,” she said. “I was just done with the Democrats, so I changed to no party. So I pick whoever I want.”

Nilka said she intends to register as a Republican before the next election cycle. “I’m going to switch to Republican,” she said, adding that she was disappointed President Donald Trump had not fully endorsed Sliwa for mayor.

She said she supports Sliwa because of his long-standing presence in the city. “Curtis, what you see him doing is not fake because he’s been doing this for years with the Guardian Angels. So he has my vote.”

Voters show off their badge of participation on the first day of early votingPhoto by Adam Daly

The lifelong Lower East Sider said she believes Mamdani represents a Democratic Party that has changed beyond recognition.

On Friday, House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries became the latest of several high-ranking Democrats to endorse the DSA-backed Mamdani, following his convincing win in the Democratic primary months earlier.

Nilka also voiced anger toward Independent candidate Cuomo, saying he has “blood on his hands” over his handling of COVID-19 in nursing homes. The talking point throughout the campaign season stems from an order from Cuomo’s state Health Department in the deadly spring of 2020, which permitted COVID-positive patients to be readmitted into nursing homes. Cuomo and his campaign have maintained there is no evidence to suggest the move caused additional deaths and that the order was exploited by his rivals for political purposes.

Other voters across. the city shared Nilka’s disillusionment but not her political shift.

Two women voting Saturday, one from Queens and the other from Brooklyn, said they were unhappy with the mayoral candidate choices but would likely vote for Mamdani.

“I think that I will vote for him,” said Marcia, a Brooklyn Democrat. “We need a change right now. Let’s give him a break.”

Marcia, who lives in East New York, said crime and safety were among her biggest concerns. “Every weekend there’s a shooting, a drug deal,” she said. “We need to keep the streets clean. I’m tired of hearing gunshots every time I go to bed.”

The first day of early voting sees New Yorkers at Lower East Side Preparatory High School turning out for the mayoral race in particularPhoto by Adam Daly

Linda, Eddie and Lee show off their ‘I Voted’ stickers after casting their ballots for Mamdani at Lower East Side Preparatory High SchoolPhoto by Adam Daly

Lisa, who lives on the Lower East Side, said she supports Mamdani despite criticisms of his lack of experience and young age. “He seems like a smart person,” she said. “He knows how to bring the right people in and make decisions.”

Atif said he hopes Mamdani’s election will shift national politics to the left.

“I’m tired of seeing the left in many different countries try to play to the center, and they become the center,” he said. “I think what we need to do is really push for the left politics.”

“Even if he doesn’t win, he’s changing the conversation,” he added.

Mitchell Aberman proudly showcases his “I Voted Early” sticker after casting his ballot in the 2025 general election on the first day of early voting in Brooklyn on Oct. 25, 2025.Photo by Lloyd Mitchell

People wait to cast their vote in the general election in Brooklyn on Oct. 25, 2025.Photo by Lloyd Mitchell

People were all smiles after early voting in Brooklyn on Oct. 25, 2025.Photo by Lloyd Mitchell

Still, Nilka, one of the Lower East Side voters, said she’s preparing for a change of scenery if Sliwa doesn’t prevail, and Mamdani does.

“If it’s Mamdani, I’m out of here like a bat out of hell,” she said. “Straight to Florida, or maybe Connecticut or New Jersey. Anywhere but here.”

Visit the NYC Board of Elections poll finder to find your early voting site.