65° Good Morning
65° Good Morning

James Blake testifies at NYPD officer's departmental trial over mistaken arrest

James Blake speaks outside police headquarters in Manhattan

James Blake speaks outside police headquarters in Manhattan on Tuesday, Sept. 19, 2017, after his testimony in NYPD Officer James Frascatore's police departmental trial. Photo Credit: Newsday / Anthony Destefano

NYPD Officer James Frascatore, seen in a highly publicized video throwing former tennis star James Blake to the ground and arresting him outside a Manhattan hotel, testified Tuesday he took such strong physical action because he mistakenly believed the athlete was a fraud suspect who might have been armed with a knife.

In testimony at his departmental trial, Frascatore, 40, of Nassau County, said he ran across a busy 42nd Street to arrest Blake on Sept. 9, 2015 outside the Hyatt Regency to get the element of surprise and had no intention of hurting him.

“I was told he was carrying a knife, that was good enough for me,” Frascatore said, explaining the way he took Blake down to the sidewalk and handcuffed him.

But Frascatore admitted that he and fellow cops quickly determined that they had wrongfully targeted Blake, who was waiting outside the hotel for a ride to the U.S. Open, and saw that he wasn’t the suspect they were seeking in an identity fraud investigation. Blake was then allowed to go, officials said.

Frascatore, a six-year veteran of the NYPD who is on modified assignment, is facing a departmental charge that he used improper physical force against Blake. He is being tried by a Civilian Complaint Review Board prosecutor before NYPD Deputy Commissioner for Trials Rosemarie Maldonado.

Defense attorney Stephen Worth said Frascatore could potentially face termination if found guilty or perhaps lose some vacation days.

On Tuesday morning, Blake testified he first thought Frascatore might be an old friend running up to him as a joke outside the hotel.

“I thought it was a friendly encounter until I was on the ground,” Blake, 37, testified under questioning by Jonathan Fogel, the CCRB prosecutor.

Blake was prepared to shake off the encounter but, after speaking to his wife Emily, decided to publicize the police action as a way of holding officers accountable.

“This should never happen to other people,” Blake said in his testimony. “There has to be accountability to everyone.”

“I don’t think we would be here if we didn’t have the video,” Blake told reporters outside police headquarters. “If not for that, it would be my word, as credible as I am, against five officers who would most likely tell a different story.”

Blake said while he initially intended to sue the city, he withdrew a notice of claim and ultimately settled after the city agreed to fund a fellowship at the Civilian Complaint Review Board and agreed to pay him and his attorney $171,000 in expenses.

Worth told reporters the video showed that Frascatore acted professionally in taking down Blake.

“Police, despite all their best efforts, make mistakes,” Worth said. “It is a human endeavor and human endeavors are imperfect.”

The trial is scheduled to resume Wednesday with testimony of an expert on police tactics.

Correction: Jonathan Fogel, a Civilian Complaint Review Board prosecutor, was misidentified in a previous version of this story.


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

News photos & videos