81° Good Evening
81° Good Evening

Train cars getting dirtier: Report

A report by the Straphangers Campaign released on

A report by the Straphangers Campaign released on March 20, 2014 found that subway cars are getting dirtier. Photo Credit: Getty Images / Mario Tama

The subway system is an inherently dirty place, but train cars are getting filthier, according to a Straphangers Campaign's survey released Thursday.

The transit riders advocacy group said 42% of the train cars surveyed in 2013 were clean, a 10-point decline from a similar 2011 survey. The worst offender was the D train, a line where just 17% of cars were clean. The cleanest ride in the system goes to the L train, where 63% of cars surveyed were dirt-free.

"The MTA's maintained the same level of cleaners although ridership's gone up," said Jason Chin-Fatt, a field organizer with Straphangers Campaign. "Riders are starting to see shmutzier floors, filled with grime, lots of food particles."

The Straphangers Campaign looked at 100 subway cars on each of the 20 train lines between September and December at rush hour, evening and overnight hours during the week and on weekends. The level of cleanliness ranged from scuff marks and ground-in gum spots to dry sticky spots and food on the floor.

"We focused on the grime," Chin-Fatt said. "It's something that riders can readily see or smell from the ground or the seat."

Of the 20 lines surveyed, nine saw a significant decrease in train car cleanliness, while the rest were largely the same from the 2011 survey.

New York City Transit disputed the Straphangers Campaign's methodology, arguing that the agency's own surveys are more statistically accurate. NYCT surveys a minimum of 250 cars per line over six months and includes the amount of litter strewn about a car and graffiti, the MTA said.

Further, the Straphangers Campaign's survey was conducted while trains were in operation.

"It's like telling someone their teeth are dirty because they haven't brushed since this morning," MTA spokesman Kevin Ortiz said. "We simply disagree with the straphangers' flawed methodology."

According to the latest MTA statistics on subway car appearance, cleanliness slightly improved systemwide last year compared to 2012, with the biggest improvements on the C, B and J and Z lines.

A recent MTA passenger satisfaction survey said nearly three-quarters of riders were satisfied or very satisfied with subway cars' overall cleanliness.


We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.

News photos & videos