LATEST PAPER
65° Good Evening
65° Good Evening
Eat and Drink

Thanksgiving desserts: NYC's most unique holiday treats

This Thanksgiving, wow your guests with pies, cakes and treats that aren't what's expected. Who knows, one of these might just become a new holiday tradition.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds' Salty Honey pie

This cult favorite is comprised of, yes, salt
Photo Credit: Four & Twenty Blackbirds

This cult favorite is comprised of, yes, salt and honey, for a salty-sweet combo. $38; preorder at birdsblack.com, pick up at 439 Third Ave., Gowanus, or Brooklyn Public Library, 10 Grand Army Plaza, Park Slope.

Butter & Scotch's S'mores Pie

Graham cracker crust is filled with creamy Callebaut
Photo Credit: Meredith Deliso

Graham cracker crust is filled with creamy Callebaut milk chocolate ganache and topped with marshmallow fluff. $35; Preorder by 11/20, pick up at 818 Franklin Ave., Crown Heights, butterandscotch.com

Milk Bar's Caramel Apple Pie

Apple compote and caramel fill a salty-sweet pretzel
Photo Credit: Milk Bar

Apple compote and caramel fill a salty-sweet pretzel crust topped with caramel and white chocolate. $44; preorder by Nov. 23 at milkbarstore.com, available for pickup at any NYC location.

Breads Bakery's Chocolate Babka Pie

Babka and pie collide in baker Uri Scheft's
Photo Credit: Meredith Deliso

Babka and pie collide in baker Uri Scheft's unique creation. $35 ($49 online); preorder before Thanksgiving (bakery closed Thanksgiving day), 18 E. 16th St., 212-633-2253, breadsbakery.com.

Treat House's Gobble Me Up

This gourmet take on the popular kid's treat,
Photo Credit: Treat House

This gourmet take on the popular kid's treat, comprised of crisp rice cereal and marshmallows, is topped with a turkey made out of chocolate and candy corn, and is one of several Thanksgiving-themed items available. $24 (for a 12-pack); preorder before Wednesday for delivery or pick-up in store (closed Thanksgiving day), 452 Amsterdam Ave., 212- 799-7779, treathouse.com.

Tate’s Bake Shop’s Chocolate Chip Pie

This dense treat is a cross between a
Photo Credit: Meredith Deliso

This dense treat is a cross between a brownie, chocolate chip cookie and fudge. $23; preorder by Nov. 21 at Butterfield Market, 1114 Lexington Ave., 212-288-7800, butterfieldmarket.com, for pick up or delivery, or order at tatesbakeshop.com.

Hill Country Chicken's Mini Pies

Choose from an assortment of bourbon pecan, caramel
Photo Credit: Hill Country Chicken

Choose from an assortment of bourbon pecan, caramel apple, double cherry, whiskey buttermilk and more. Starting at $4.25; order by 11/24 at 5 p.m., available for pick up at 1123 Broadway, 212-257-6446, or 34 Adams St., Downtown Brooklyn, 718-885-4609, hillcountrychicken.com.

Francois Payard's Gingerbread Cake

For some holiday flavor, this cake is comprised
Photo Credit: Francois Payard

For some holiday flavor, this cake is comprised of gingerbread spiced pound cake, gingerbread mousse and a white chocolate and cranberry gelee. $28-$65; pre-order at payard.com, available for delivery or pickup at 116 W. Houston St. or 1293 Third Ave.

Pie Corps's Pie Pops

Go hands-free this Thanksgiving with these pies on
Photo Credit: Meredith Deliso

Go hands-free this Thanksgiving with these pies on a stick, available in apple pie filling. $36 (for a dozen); preorder at piecorps.com, pick up at 77 Driggs Ave., Greenpoint, 917-721-3052

Eat and Drink photos & videos