Residents, politicians rally against L.E.S. Pathmark closure

Addressing the proposed closure of the Pathmark supermarket on Cherry Street, Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver told local residents and community leaders, “We’ve fought this battle before, and we’ll fight it again.” Downtown Express photo by Sam Spokony.

BY SAM SPOKONY  | Around a hundred Lower East Side residents gathered alongside community leaders and politicians on Wed., Oct. 10 to rally against the impending closure of a Pathmark supermarket, which would pave the way for a largely unwelcome, upscale residential development.

“This community is stunned that we will very soon be deprived of a very basic need in our neighborhood,” said Victor Papa, president of the Two Bridges Neighborhood Council, at the rally outside the Pathmark at 227 Cherry St. “And that need is the affordable food and medicine that this [supermarket and pharmacy] has provided for nearly three decades.”

A&P, which owns Pathmark, announced on Sept. 28 that the Cherry Street supermarket will close at the end of December due to the sale of its lease to an unidentified party. An A&P spokesperson said the corporation is relinquishing the lease to accommodate a “large scale residential development and improvement project, while preserving the right to operate once the project is complete.”

The community’s immediate outrage at the announcement has continued steadily since then, especially among the many low-income, public housing residents and seniors who live within walking distance of the Pathmark and have few other options for grocery shopping.

“I love my Pathmark, and I would really miss it,” said Dalia Soto, who came to the Oct. 10 rally from her home in the nearby LaGuardia Houses, where she has lived for over 50 years.

Soto added that, for the past 15 years, she has done basically all of her grocery shopping at the Cherry Street supermarket. If it were to close as planned, her only other option would be to shop at the Fine Fare supermarket on Clinton Street, near Grand Street — but the walk back and forth would be too long, she said, and the Fine Fare just doesn’t compare with the value offered by Pathmark.

Another LaGuardia Houses resident, Ruth Hawkins, showed up at the rally waving her most recent Pathmark receipt, which showed that she had saved more than $1,300 so far this year by using the store’s member discount card.

“That’s money for my family,” said Hawkins, who is currently unemployed and looking for work. “It’s really scary, because we just can’t afford to shop anywhere else.”

State Assembly Speaker Sheldon Silver, who helped lead a similar and successful fight in 2007, when the Cherry Street Pathmark was in danger of being replaced by a residential development, gave spirited and optimistic remarks at Wednesday’s gathering.

“We’ve fought this battle before, and we’ll fight it again,” Silver told the crowd — before adding, amid cheers, his firm belief that, “We’ll win!”

Silver, Manhattan Borough President Scott Stringer, State Senator Daniel Squadron, City Council Member Margaret Chin and U.S. Congress Member Nydia Velazquez — all of whom were on hand at the rally, except for Velazquez — sent an Oct. 5 letter to A&P’s chief executive officer, F. Roy Schoenberg, imploring him to work collaboratively with community leaders in order to ease the burden on local residents.

After the rally, Silver said that the politicians hope to meet with A&P executives, Schoenberg and the new developer as soon as possible, though a meeting has yet to be scheduled.

Papa later explained that, although he hasn’t received confirmation, he has good reason to believe that the developer now in control of the 227 Cherry St. lease is the Extell Development Company, which is led by Gary Barnett. A spokesperson representing Barnett declined to comment.

Extell’s residential properties are all massive luxury apartment buildings.

The company is currently constructing the 90-story One57 building in Midtown, which, at just over 1,000 feet, will be the tallest residential building in the city once it is completed next year. One57’s duplex penthouse sold for over $90 million last May.

Soto, the LaGuardia Houses resident, said she believes a luxury building would simply feel out of place at 227 Cherry St. “This isn’t Fifth Avenue,” she said. “We’re just regular people.”