Signs point to Sears closing Brooklyn store, its last outpost in New York City

Signs point to a coming shutdown of the last Sears store in New York City, in Flatbush, Brooklyn.
Gabriel Sandoval/THE CITY

Logo for THE CITY

This article was originally published on by THE CITY

A liquidation sale is on at the Flatbush retailer, part of what was once a national retail juggernaut. Landmarking will protect the building but what comes next is unknown.

In Flatbush, a beloved Sears department store has remained in business since 1932, its Art Deco building a relic of a bygone era that’s now a protected city landmark.  

But signs point to the end of line for the chain department store, known for its architecture and 100-foot tower at the corner of Beverly Road and Bedford Avenue.

Among them: flashy sale posters plastered on the front door. “EVERYTHING MUST GO!” reads one at the entrance. Another reads: “FURNITURE, FIXTURES AND EQUIPMENT FOR SALE.”

Sears is advertising jobs for “Store Closing-Brooklyn,” and a company specializing in retail store liquidations has the Beverly Road store on its Sears “store closing list.” Sears filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy protection in 2018.

The store — the last remaining Sears outpost in New York City — has been a shopping staple for generations of families in the Brooklyn neighborhood. 

“When we lose good things, it becomes heart-rending,” said Lorna Phillips, 60, a clothing designer originally from Jamaica who’s lived in Flatbush for 38 years. 

She said the closure will be a major loss for the community, and she’ll miss finding good deals. Over the years, she’s gotten low prices on everything from perfume, blankets and a vacuum cleaner, to a DVD player when the technology first came out in the 1990s.

A Kmart housed in the basement of the three-story building is also set to close. Kmart — a brand that merged with Sears — closed its last outpost in Manhattan in July, now slated to be replaced by a Wegman’s grocery store.

Signs advertise a liquidation sale at the Sears on Beverly Road in Flatbush, Brooklyn.Gabriel Sandoval/THE CITY

Since Sears’ reign as a retail juggernaut peaked in the 1980s, declining sales have led to the closure of hundreds of Sears locations across the country. Sears and Kmart’s parent company, Transformco, did not respond to THE CITY’s request for comment.

Sears is shuttering its last store in its home state of Illinois, CNBC reported Thursday.

One Sears cashier told THE CITY that workers expect the Brooklyn store to close in December. 

The Flatbush Sears closed temporarily at the start of the pandemic, and in April 2020 its sprawling parking lot became one of former Governor Andrew Cuomo’s drive-through coronavirus testing sites aimed at communities disproportionately affected by COVID-19. 

Landmarked Building

In 2012, the building received a landmark designation from the city Landmarks Preservation Commission, protecting its façade based on its historical significance. That means that even once Sears is gone, the building — including its distinctive limestone SEARS tower rising above Flatbush — must remain as is and cannot be demolished.

Initially named Sears, Roebuck & Company, the department store opened on November 5, 1932. Eleanor Roosevelt, while her husband was still New York governor and a presidential candidate, addressed hundreds of people at the grand opening. 

Roosevelt reportedly turned the key to open the store and made the first purchase “a pair of baby’s booties,” according to coverage in the Brooklyn Daily Eagle newspaper. 

Nearly a century later as the store prepares to close, children’s clothing is still sold there. 

On Thursday, local Natalie Acosta passed by the Sears as she walked her 7-year-old daughter home from school. Acosta said they’ll miss the affordable prices.  

“I got her winter stuff, a whole ski suit, for literally $3,” said Acosta, 34. 

She added that she’s seen the store go from bustling with business to struggling to attract customers in the seven years that she’s lived in the neighborhood. 

“I’m surprised it’s even lasted this long,” she said. 

“I would love if it were booming like it was before, because it’s a great department store,” she added. 

Acosta said she hoped a movie theater would open in its place. Her daughter, Nayafelix, said she would like another store with “more toys.”   

Phillips said whatever comes after Sears should benefit the community.  

“If they’re gonna bring back stores, bring something more classy or something that will still serve the neighborhood in a good way,” she said.

THE CITY is an independent, nonprofit news outlet dedicated to hard-hitting reporting that serves the people of New York.

More from around NYC