Assembly speaker Heastie urges patience on NY bail reform

New York Legislature
Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie, D-Bronx, speaks to reporters about legislation progress outside the Assembly Chamber at the state Capitol Wednesday, June 19, 2019, in Albany, N.Y. (AP Photo/Hans Pennink)


An intensified debate over New York’s bail law continued at the State Capitol on Thursday, with the top Democrat in the State Assembly saying he wants to let the reforms play out without changes.

State Assembly Speaker Carl Heastie urged people to have patience with the newly implemented bail law, which has received increasing scrutiny over its rules that allow New York courts to release people who would have remained in jail under the old rules.

The law, which went into place at the beginning of the year, eliminated cash bail and pretrial detention for a wide majority of low-level cases and nonviolent felonies. The law also allows courts to release a person under certain conditions, such as a travel or firearm restriction.

“We want safe communities, but it is important to have a criminal justice system that treats everybody fairly,” Heastie, a Democrat from the Bronx, told reporters Thursday.

Meanwhile, his counterpart in the state Senate, Majority Leader Andrea Stewart-Cousins, said Democrats are monitoring to see if any “tweaks” are needed to the bail reform law. But, she asserted Democrats don’t want to criminalize poverty or continue with a broken system.

Bail reform supporters argue the changes help prevent poor people from languishing in jail for low-level crimes.

Both Democratic legislative leaders were responding to attacks from Republicans, who have lambasted the reforms and argue the changes have jeopardized public safety. Changing or rolling back the bail reforms has emerged as a top priority for Senate Republicans.

“We’re going to hammer this every single day,” said John Flanagan, the Republican minority state Senate leader. The Long Island senator said he believes they will see tragedies if lawmakers don’t act immediately.

Flanagan said he supports giving more discretion to judges over who can be held in jail before their trial, among other changes.

Heastie pushed back at the idea and said allowing a judge’s perspective can invite bias into bail decisions.