SportsIslanders Islanders drop Game 3 in overtime, fall behind Lightning 2-1 in series Tampa Bay Lightning right wing Ryan Callahan (24) jumps into the arms of teammate Tampa Bay Lightning center Brian Boyle (11) after the winning goal in overtime in Game 3 of the Eastern Conference semifinals against the New York Islanders on Tuesday, May 3, 2016 at Barclays Center. Photo Credit: Jim McIsaac By Arthur Staple firstname.lastname@example.org May 3, 2016 11:01 PM Print Share fbShare Tweet Email Resiliency has been the Islanders’ rallying cry all season. They’ll need as much of that trait as they can muster after a deflating 5-4 overtime loss to the Lightning last night at Barclays Center that gives Tampa Bay a 2-1 series lead. Brian Boyle had all the time he needed to collect a shot off the end boards and snap it past the prone Thomas Greiss at 2:48 of overtime for the win — he had all that time after he appeared to catch Thomas Hickey with an elbow to the head as the Lightning entered the Islanders zone, leaving Hickey dazed and out of the play as Tampa converted the winner. “I don’t know what the refs’ explanation is . . . The guy’s laying on the ice, you should make the call,” Travis Hamonic said. “Whatever I can say, I’ll probably get in trouble. We’ve got to bounce back. No choice.” The Islanders were less than a minute away from taking the series lead in regulation when Nikita Kucherov snapped one past Greiss with 38.4 seconds to play with the Tampa net empty. The Lightning had the puck in the Isles zone for over a minute before Jonathan Drouin found Kucherov for a quick shot from the slot to send the game to OT. Cal Clutterbuck’s goal with 8:23 left in the third broke a 3-3 tie and could have been the deciding goal in a see-saw game. Jason Garrison’s pass caromed off Casey Cizikas’ skate and out to Clutterbuck, who ripped one past Ben Bishop to give the Isles their third lead of the game. “You’ve just got to not get too high or too low,” Johnny Boychuk said. “We’ve won a few of these already, it’s our first OT loss. I thought we played well for the most part.” But they could not pull away from a fairly resilient Lightning team. After a very strong first period for the Isles that ended 1-1 after Josh Bailey, back in the lineup after a two-game absence, scored from in tight at 7:55 and Ryan Callahan tipped one past Greiss on a Tampa power play with 12.5 seconds to go in the first, Hickey leveled Drouin as he entered the Isles zone. There was no penalty and none expected on the shoulder hit from Hickey. Drouin went to the dressing room and the Isles went to a power play after Hickey took a chop to the head. But the Lightning took the lead at 8:10 on Victor Hedman’s ripper off a faceoff win. Tampa controlled much of the play for the next few minutes until the Isles fourth line worked well below the goal line and Clutterbuck fed Nick Leddy for the tying goal at 14:50. The teams traded goals in a 58-second span early in the third, with Bailey scoring his second of the night off a pretty feed from Hickey at 2:27 and Vlad Namestnikov converting an Isles turnover into a 3-3 game at 3:25. With the lead in the closing minutes, the Isles had chances to retrieve the puck and clear the zone, but failed. Drouin, who returned midway through the third, passed through three Islanders and found his man for the tie. “Obviously it stings, you’re so close,” said John Tavares, who was held without a point for the second straight game and was on the ice for Kucherov’s tying goal. “We’ve got to do a better job with that opportunity and a lot of that is on me.” In overtime, the entire Islanders bench was yelling at referees Steve Kozari and Brad Watson, the latter of whom stared right at Hickey as he fell and Boyle entered the zone four on two. “I don’t know, it kind of boggles my mind a little bit,” Tavares said. “Obviously they see it differently. He’s down. I don’t know. None of them saw it, they said. I found it hard to believe.” Now the Islanders have to come from behind in a series for the first time this postseason and show some of that resiliency before it’s too late. Arthur Staple’sStars of the Game3 Stars1 -- Brian Boyle -- the controversial OT winner.2 -- Josh Bailey -- two goals in a strong return to the lineup.3 -- Nikita Kucherov -- another huge goal late in regulation for Tampa’s top scorer. By Arthur Staple email@example.com Arthur Staple was the Islanders beat writer. He has been at Newsday since 1997 and has covered hockey for more than a decade. Share on Facebook Share on Twitter Comments We're revamping our Comments section. Learn more and share your input.